I'm sure that many of you have watched an Anime that was adapted from Manga's and found it not as good, if not worse then the Manga...
For example, Spiral: The Bonds of Reasoning had an Anime for it which ranged 25 Episodes. The Anime itself wasn't bad per say, but it didn't answer many questions unlike what the Manga did, the ending itself leaves you a bit unsatisfied, especially to those who haven't even read the Manga, thus are left in the dark...
Another would be Soul Eater, It too started with a promising start, though in the final episodes it began to turn to a different form, in which the very ending itself left many exited fans extremely disappointed with how it all ended...
So tell me what you think guys, what do think made these Anime's live to the expectations of their Manga versions...? Is it that their wasn't enough Episodes, or is it cause it didn't follow the Manga completely or was it something else completely...?
Let me hear what YOU think...? :D
|
395
7
|
|
0
|
In Code Geass manga there are 3 sides lelouch, Nunnaly, and Suzaku.(Damn him) The anime only did Lelouch. WHAT THE CRAP IS THAT?! 7 months, 4 weeks ago
add comment
|
|
0
|
Kuroshitsuji. The manga is fairly new so there wasn't enough material for the anime which meant... Fillers! I don't mind fillers so much if they follow the feel of the manga, but it didn't happen here. The characters were completely out of character compared to the manga. Also the dark themes in the manga were turned into humor. And I also agree on Spiral 11 months ago
|
|
1
|
Yeah, I hear Soul Eater's anime ending was a giant letdown. I'm still getting there myself however. xxxHolic would've also been way better if it had followed the manga. Provided it's already really good, but the manga storyline is EPIC!!! 11 months, 1 week ago
|
|
1
|
most are 11 months, 1 week ago
|
|
3
|
I would say Soul Eater is the best example. I've also heard that the first FMA series was like that, though I never watched it for a while. 11 months, 1 week ago
comments
Indeed, Soul Eater Ending made me stay stunned for a whole hour after watching, then I quckly snapped back and RAGED...! xD
I only saw a couple of Episodes of the original after reading the Manga, but quickly dumped it seeing it turned out... =/ -
Amon
11 months, 1 week ago
*I only saw a couple of Episodes from the original FMA after reading the Manga, but quickly dumped it seeing it turned out... =/
To me Brotherhood did it more justice... =D -
Amon
11 months, 1 week ago
I watched every episode...It was great at first. Then Chrona got stabbed, then Medusa was killed, and then finally Asura was killed with one hit. That just spoiled the whole anime. -
False_Messiah
11 months, 1 week ago
FFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUU------------- You jerk, you just spoiled one of the anime that I was going to watch. D: j/k I don't care about spoilers. But you should be more careful in the future. -
Albireo
11 months, 1 week ago
Ah, sorry about that...I'll try to not spoil it then XD -
False_Messiah
11 months, 1 week ago
|
|
2
|
(@Albireo since it was too long for a Comment... xD;) I disagree with you on that last point, cause in my view it's the other way around... Most Anime's that are adapted from Manga's don't last long as much the Manga does... A familiar scene as such is it cutting off at the ending, while as the manga continues much more...! That's why I feel both joy and fear when I see an Anime of my Favorite manga... xD; Joy at the site of something I enjoyed reading coming to life while as fear at the possibility it wouldn't tale the story to it's full content and just stop abruptly before reaching even deeper to where the Manga stops or even the point it has reached at that time... I've seen this happen to many times in the past, though I can't say how they can fix it since most NEW Anime's would have 25 Episodes at best( Though there are some which go even higher then that...) A solution to this would be another season for the Anime, but very few get this chance... 11 months, 1 week ago
|
|
3
|
Also, without the fillersodes, the story goes alot quicker in the manga which is nice. Unlike in Dragonball Z: ......"KA!!!!" (episode 26)..."ME" (episode 27)..."HA" (episode 28)..."ME" (episode 29)..."HHHHAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAA!!!!!!!!!!!!!!" (episode 30) finally!! 11 months, 1 week ago
|
|
2
|
My opinion: Once an anime starts putting in the filler episodes, it's worse than the manga. >_> Just saying... 11 months, 1 week ago
comments
Haha, that's true sometimes... xD
But Hayate no Gotoku (Season 1) had those, so does that apply to that as well...? =0 -
Amon
11 months, 1 week ago
That depends on how season 2 goes. Season 2 is supposed to be following the manga pretty much all the way. AND I never said that an anime can't get good again. -
Albireo
11 months, 1 week ago
Don't get me wrong. I prefer watching the anime version of ANYTHING over than reading the manga version. This is my own preference though, as anime episodes last much, much longer than a chapter or two of a manga. -
Albireo
11 months, 1 week ago
The only problem that I have with filler episodes is that they don't contribute towards the story of the anime in any way. A manga is better for instant gratification, but an anime lasts much longer. -
Albireo
11 months, 1 week ago
|
Post a Reply
Please login to post a reply.
Related Posts
Markdown Hints
*italics*
**bold**
[Link text](example.com)
Basic HTML should work :)